(a)Harmony.Anti-gaybeliefsandpoliciesaretypicallymotivatedbyemotionalprejudice,andusuallynotcalmjudgmentaboutsocialwelfare.Whenpublicpolicyisdrivenbyprejudiceagainstanunpopularminority,socialharmonywillsuffer.Thisisthecasewithanti-gaypolicies,especiallypersecutions.Theyservenopublicpurposeandoftenexistsimplytoexpressdisgustorevenhatetowardaminority.
Althoughnooneknowswhat“causes”peopletohaveparticularsexualorientations,scientistshaveconcludedthathomosexualityisnotaconsciouschoice.Norisitassociatedwithhyper-sexualityorevenartisticabilities.Lesbiansandgaymenareprettymuchindistinguishablefromtherestofthepopulation,exceptfortheirsexualtastes.Onetothreepercentofthepersonsinanysocietyarehomosexualinorientation(Posner,1992).Scientistshavealsoconcluded,evenmorefirmly,thathomosexualityisnotamentaldisease,sickness,ordefect.Indeed,itis“homophobia,”emotionalhatredofhomosexuality,thatscientistssayisthepathology,thementaldisease(e.g.,UnitedStatesNationalInstituteofMentalHealth,TaskForceonHomosexuality,1969).
Giventhesefacts,publicpersecutionoflesbiansandgaymenisparticularlywastefulandsociallydisastrous.Thegovernmenthaslimitedcrime-fightingresources,andthereisplentyofaggressive,irresponsibleactivityinanymoderncountry.Todivertpreciousresourcesawayfrompredatoryandassaultiveactivities,towardpersecutingaharmlessminorityisextremelyunproductive.Moreimportant,itunderminesthepossibilityofsocialharmony.Policiesofpersecution,whenthevictimsareasociallyproductivegroup,stirupsocialhatredsandempowerthemostviciousamongcitizens.ThiswascertainlytheexperienceintheUnitedStatesduringthe1950s.Inthenameofnationalsecurity,thousandsofAmericanhomosexualswerehuntedlikedogs,andourcountry’spoliticswasforabrieftimedominatedbycrazypeople,whoseprejudice-basedcampaignsagainst“Communists”and“sexperverts”turnedcitizensagainstoneanother(Johnson,2004).